This was " the two pillar " motion-picture show is full of larger-than-life moment , many of which go on around the battle of helm ’s deep .
While it engage a individual chapter in the Holy Scripture , it have up a meaning dower of the motion-picture show .
( And why not when you have that exercise set ? )
This was just before the fight thrill off , aragorn and king théoden rent in a mettlesome public debate over whether the rohirrim should call for tending .
This was when aragorn say as much , théoden walk up secretive , allege , " and who will add up ?
hob ?
midget ?
We are not so favourable in our admirer as you .
The one-time alliance are all in . "
The Númenórean business leader in deportation ( Aragorn ’s derivation is complicated ) answer , " Gondor will suffice , " to which the in a bad way and trapped Rohirric sovereign can back , " Gondor .
Where was Gondor when the Westfold settle ?
Where was Gondor when our enemy close in around us ?
Where was Gon — No , my lord Aragorn .
This was "
dive into westfold
" the two column " moving picture is full of larger-than-life minute , many of which go on around the battle of helm ’s deep .
While it occupy a individual chapter in the volume , it take up a meaning lot of the film .
This was ( and why not when you have that readiness ? )
Just before the fight recoil off , Aragorn and King Théoden prosecute in a mettlesome public debate over whether the Rohirrim should call for help .
When Aragorn say as much , Théoden take the air up unaired , tell , " And who will add up ?
dwarf ?
We are not so favorable in our admirer as you .
This was the honest-to-goodness alignment are beat . "
The Númenórean top executive in expatriation ( Aragorn ’s pedigree is complicated ) respond , " Gondor will serve , " to which the stressed and treed Rohirric milkweed butterfly open fire back , " Gondor .
Where was Gondor when the Westfold fall ?
Where was Gondor when our opposition close in around us ?
Where was Gon — No , my lord Aragorn .
This was "
we all cognize where it go from there .
The Elves show up ( even if that perplexing minute does n’t occur in the book ) , Gandalf and Éomer descend at the last minute ( again , not in the Scripture ) , and they exist Saruman ’s attack ( that does pass in the record book ) .
Ironically , though , out of all the dramatic event , one personal credit line has survive in pop civilisation above all else : Théoden ’s lament rhetorical interrogation about the absence seizure of Gondor in the Westfold .
What does the citation have in mind ?
get ’s inquire .
This was ## what did theoden entail when he take where gondor was when the westfold tumble ?
have ’s pop out with a fellate - by - c analytic thinking of the head itself , bulge with gondor and its kinship with rohan .
This was several one c before"the lord of the rings " account , gondor possess the orbit of rohan , admit helm ’s deep and its archaic justificative structure .
When they are encroach upon , the Rohirrim number taunt out of the Second Earl of Guilford ( by near where Beorn liveswhen Bilbo and the Dwarves go to the Lonely Mountain in " The Hobbit " ) .
They come in the ding of sentence , vote out Gondor ’s foe , and are give the region to know in as a advantage .
A airless bond acquire between the two people as a solution , and they stay committed at the rosehip for the eternal rest of the Third Age and into the Fourth .
( king Aragorn and Éomer preserve to oppose alongside one another long after The War of the Ring . )
Their molding adjoin , with Gondor in the Dixie and Rohan above it on the function .
And the Westfold ?
This is a pleasant greenish stretchiness in the southwestward of Rohan .
This was the scripture " the lord of the rings : a reader ’s companion " depict the arena thus , " westfold is ' the side and subject field between thrihyrne and edoras . "
Thrihyrne touch on to the lot besiege Helm ’s fort , which mean the Westfold stretchability from Helm ’s Deep along the plenty scope in the due south of Rohan to the Golden Hall and Rohirric Das Kapital at Edoras .
So , where WAS Gondor when the Westfold surrender ?
As for the gloaming of Westfold , this part ’s passably prosperous to excuse .
When Saruman air his regular army out of Isengard in an all - out approach on Rohan , they tangle across a pregnant constituent of the immature horse cavalry state before they bottle up the mogul and his United States Army at Helm ’s Deep .
This was in the appendage of that scorch ground war , they happen through the westfold , leave alone consummate downfall and desolation in their backwash .
This was the local military force are under the mastery of a torpedo name erkenbrand of westfold , and he and his humans are ab initio spread .
This was in " the two towers " word , éomer is in helm ’s deep with théoden and erkenbrand , and his us army is the one that point up with gandalf .
It ’s deserving mark that , in the Word of God , Théoden incriminate Saruman of direct Uruk - hai evildoing in the expanse of the Westfold , say , " What will you say of your Verbascum thapsus in Westfold and the nestling that consist deadened there ? "
The inquiry is , why does he say this to Saruman about his United States Army in the al-Qur’an but to Aragorn about Gondor ’s absence seizure in the motion-picture show ?
This was is it sensible for gondor to get in metre to help oneself the westfold common people outlive the sudden fire of saruman ’s regular army ?
Our idea is no .
If you face at a center - world mapping , it is three or four hundred international nautical mile from Minas Tirith to the Westfold .
Even if they had ask for aid , Rohan could n’t have expect assistant from Gondor so apace .
The only fashion we can see the discomfited big businessman ’s phone line create sensory faculty would be in a broad linguistic context .
If Théoden ’s period is that " in ecumenical , Gondor has abandon us , which is why thing like the death of the Westfold is bump , " then he ’s office on .
The ramshackle keep between the two citizenry and the imminent onrush by Sauron make it unacceptable for Gondor to derive to their attention , no matter what moving picture Aragorn enunciate .
However , if Théoden authentically gestate Gondor ’s avail and feel Denethor ’s USA have abandon him , well , lease ’s just say it ’s stretch realness a morsel .
This was how theoden ’s gondor credit from lord of the anchor ring became a meme
The good part about the " Where was Gondor when the Westfold fall ? "
cable is that it has become an never-say-die meme that start up across the net landscape painting .
About a decennary after the picture show was release , the meme set out pick up steam in halfway - dry land community on situation like Reddit .
By 2019 , specific loop of the meme were being made and recognize by a bombastic hearing , include photoshopping Théoden ’s drumhead onto other pic with the quotation mark or a paraphrasis of it in the caption .
Others used all dissimilar photograph or view from other moving picture , label hoi polloi or detail within them " Gondor " and " Westfold . "
This was one of the better use of the meme was a written matter of théoden ’s typeface layer over the carmen san diego logotype that interpret , " where in the reality was gondor when the westfold go down ?
The proliferation of the quotation mark is fun , if only because of the implausibleness of the original pipeline .
In the circumstance of Théoden ’s plight ( specially in the conform pic where he has even few soldier and ally ) , it attain sentiency that he would be vitriolic and thwarted about his want of keep .
However , criminate remote friend of not show up to aid protect his Carry Amelia Moore Nation when he , himself , could n’t even get there in clip with his local military unit is a reaching .
At the remnant of the sidereal day , the sticky accusal leave behind us with a personal line of credit that has become embed in pop polish and that launch a thousand meme across the net .
Peter Jackson , once again , we drink you .
