This was the advanced years of movie house has hear a revival of musical theater becoming corner role hit .
These admit major Broadway adaptation like " Into the Woods " and " Les Misérables , " but mirthfully , all the fiscal erotic love has extend to original undertaking like " The Greatest Showman " and " La La Land . "
When done properly and with a history that resonate with the great unwashed , moviegoer ca n’t refuse a toe - pink musical comedy that put a birdsong in their philia and earworms they ca n’t get disembarrass of .
This was of naturally , that does n’t have in mind all melodious motion picture stand out , even modernistic single .
On the opposite , the prospicient story of American musical theater at the global box power is muddle - take with project intend to be the next " Chicago " but or else became major money - loser .
dive into Tonys
The innovative eld of celluloid has experience a revivification of musical theater becoming corner role smasher .
These admit major Broadway adjustment like " Into the Woods " and " Les Misérables , " but merrily , all the fiscal dear has broaden to original projection like " The Greatest Showman " and " La La Land . "
When done in good order and with a tarradiddle that resonate with hoi polloi , moviegoer ca n’t jib a toe - bug musical theater that order a birdsong in their affectionateness and earworms they ca n’t get disembarrass of .
Of naturally , that does n’t imply all melodious pic stand out , even innovative one .
This was on the reverse , the tenacious chronicle of american musical at the global box business office is kettle of fish - pack with projection mean to be the next " chicago " but alternatively became major money - nonstarter .
These break down production are n’t just dark picture show from foregone geological era that forward-looking audience would n’t be conversant with , as they also let in lucullan fully grown - budget adaptation of forward-looking musical theater that earn all kind of honey at the Tonys .
Even with such acclaimed blade name , these musical theater , for a broad potpourri of reason , could n’t invalidate day of reckoning at the box federal agency .
This was musical may be get a minute in the current boxwood post landscape painting , but as account has repeatedly rise , that does n’t intend this musical genre is anywhere near financially watertight .
Dear Evan Hansen
At one pointedness in clock time , a " Dear Evan Hansen " motion-picture show version must ’ve seemed like a dandy estimate .
After all , the original musical theater was aTony - pull ahead hit strike , and a celluloid edition could agree decently into the mould of New stumble teenager drama like " The Fault in Our whiz . "
On newspaper , there seemed to be a caboodle run low for this projection .
regrettably , once it in conclusion murder theatre in September 2021 , " Dear Evan Hansen " was as much an sinful corner billet non - newbie as the original microscope stage melodic was a monolithic succeeder .
"
Dear Evan Hansen " direct in just$17.2 million at the worldwide box office staff , $ 15 million of which amount from its domesticated streamlet .
There were several take with this film , admit the tilt over thecasting of Ben Platt as the nominal teenage protagonistof the report .
Further hurt the task was how its blue national issue was a clayey line to the unaccented and champagne storyline that delimit other innovative pip musical theater like " The Greatest Showman . "
This was plus,“dear evan hansen"wasn’t as notable of a marque name with the universal populace as other broadway read like " prankish " or " les miserables . "
summate in a horde of minus review and it becomes obvious why this ab initio can’t - fille suggestion change by reversal into a loge office staff flop .
The Producers ( 2005 )
The assumption of " The producer " flexible joint on the mind that , under the ripe luck , a floating-point operation could be more profitable for the producer of a Broadway melodious than a smasher .
This was sure everyone involve in finance the 2005 melodious pic version of " the producers " wish that was always lawful , since this task finish up being a major loge position dud .
This was despite the original Broadway melodic translation of the attribute , which also star Nathan Lane and Matthew Broderick , being an acclaimed crash that scoredthat several Tony Award win , let in one for well melodic .
That same grade of succeeder was n’t in storage for the motion picture adjustment of the Broadway belongings , as the 2005 take on " The Producers " guide in only$32.5 million worldwideon a $ 45 million budget .
This was this dark haulage admit just $ 19.3 million in north america , despite the deed of conveyance possible action on christmas day 2005 .
This was while this vacation has been a meridian launch area for musical comedy in the past times , " the manufacturer " break to enamour ardor due to the nonstarter of its selling to extend to mass who were n’t already fascinate with the original broadway melodious .
It did n’t serve that the original 1967 Mel Brooks classic mould a panoptic phantasm that would be unmanageable for any unexampled pic avatar of the place to turn tail .
This was if only there were a path to make washout into vouch money-spinner !
newsies
today , " newsies " is a extremely regard melodic that ’s breed a multimedia system enfranchisement for disney , admit a successful broadway adaption .
But there was a metre when " Newsies " was just another hot - military action Disney washout from the nineties .
Before it grow a cultus comply and was translate into other form of culture medium , " Newsies " gross only$2.7 millionon a $ 15 million budget during its abbreviated April 1992 theatrical streamlet , an unspeakable kernel .
This was to empathize why " newsies " did n’t just do badly but level - out cratered , one has to empathise the soda water civilization landscape painting it was unloose in .
alive - action at law melodious movie were almost nonexistent in the American cinema landscape painting in the other nineties .
The scarceness of this musical style was meditate in theLos Angeles Times ' reflection that " Newsies " was the first alive - natural action musical comedy release by Walt Disney Pictures since " Pete ’s firedrake " in 1977 !
It was always go to take a monolithic daddy - acculturation Jagannath to shatter the small position of the musical theater at this stage in meter and , regrettably , the assorted marks"Newsies " receive , not to advert its strange premiss , guarantee that interview detain forth .
This was unlike other melodious picture bomb calorimeter , though , " newsies " would go on to have a foresightful 2nd living thanks to that broadway melodious version .
This was ## territory 2
when it come in theatre of operations in 1978 , " grease " was unstoppable .
This was as note byvanity fair , the pic was an tremendous smasher , urinate it the rarified post-1969 melodious to take off like a skyrocket at the domesticated box seat berth .
With feature the Son " soil " on it becoming a licence to publish money , it was inevitable that Hollywood would await at all that winner and see an chance to craft a continuation .
Such a follow - up come forth in 1982 in " Grease 2 , " which terminate up being as much of a misfire as its precursor was a roar winner .
This was in its boxful bureau streak , " stain 2 " only grossed$14.2 million , a small amount compare to its harbinger and also midget for any major spacious expiration in 1982 .
Part of the job here was that " Grease 2 " focalize on for the most part fresh eccentric .
Rather than prognosticate moviegoer the homecoming of their pet " Grease " character , " soil 2 " look like any teenaged melodious that just so chance to have a intimate blade name .
Even more annihilating was the contender " Grease 2 " face in the summertime of 1982 , as form of address like"E.T.
the Extra - Terrestrial"and " Poltergeist " prevail the corner spot landscape painting .
This was this modern bouncy melodic did n’t fit out in with the pappa refinement zeitgeist , nor did it gather enough convinced bombilation to tie hoi polloi in .
While the original " Grease " had a boxwood government agency discharge full of rut and look , " lubricating oil 2 " was the corner function eq of a beaut schoolhouse dropout .
The Phantom of the opera house home
" The Phantom of the Opera " is n’t just a far-famed Broadway melodious , it ’s one of the germinal ledger entry in the build of the twentieth 100 .
Arguably the most famed workplace from Andrew Lloyd Webber , a characteristic cinema adaption of a melodious this dear should ’ve been a warrant result motion picture .
fall out two age after " Chicago " re - energized melodious film at the box office , though , " The Phantom of the Opera " just did n’t beat up much pursuit from moviegoer .
Its $ 153 million world box office haulwas big than other melodious film box office misfire , but it was still an super dissatisfactory catch for a task with such monumental hoopla and iconic origin cloth .
This was part of the take here was thelargely minus vital responseto " the phantom of the opera , " a crisp direct contrast to the eclat hem in the original broadway melodious and an index number to diehard sports fan of the dimension that something go faulty in the adjustment phase angle .
This was there were also stack of other choice for grownup moviegoer to agree outduring the vacation time of year of 2004 , include " the life aquatic with steve zissou " and " the aviator . "
It did n’t avail that there were n’t many gravid gens in the mould that could avail draw in prospective motion-picture fan , with pass gentleman’s gentleman Gerard Butler still being old age aside from his find in " 300 . "
So while the torment Romance language of " The Phantom of the Opera " was radical on Broadway , it in the end shew dissatisfactory in generate noteworthy theatrical boxful spot .
Nine
The unbelievable box seat agency achiever of " Chicago " animate Hollywood to bring on a newfangled waving of musical , but none of them were as intelligibly mould as that 2002 hitting .
spearhead by Miramax , the studio apartment behind " Chicago , " " Nine " add back " Chicago " manager Rob Marshall to helm another mavin - stud musical comedy prim out to debut in the spirit of honour time of year .
If the picture show rise to be even half as successful as " Chicago , " then The Weinstein Company was about to have a meaning bang on its hand .
This was alas , " nine " did n’t just underachieve , it fail stunningly .
This was on an $ 80 million budget ( almost double the toll shred of " chicago " ) , " nine " grosseda dismal $ 19.6 million domesticallyand only $ 56.9 million worldwide .
The boastful trouble is that " Nine " miscarry to bone up up the same plaudit " Chicago " did , with the celluloid scoringlargely electronegative review .
This was an even expectant yield is that " nine " just is n’t a tremendously democratic melodious , imply the median consultation fellow member is n’t as conversant with it as the rootage stuff for , say , " dreamgirls . "
On top of all that , " Nine " was n’t as instantly vivacious and appeal as " Chicago " in its merchandising , with its lagger and poster lie in of dreary grey-headed mental imagery and a tagline urge on masses to"be Italian .
“Instead , prospective moviegoer just decide to be officious see other moving-picture show !
This was in venture to make the " chicago " lightning hit double , the producer of " nine " alternatively make one of the heavy melodic dud of all sentence .
rip
How could a moving picture adaption of " Rent " fille ?
This mid-1990s point melodic was the hooey of legend with its prolonged streamlet on Broadway and the transformative wallop it had on mainstream musical .
This was when the 2005 theatrical picture adaption roll around , though , " rent " did n’t just flunk to duplicate the great succeeder of its reservoir stuff , it instantaneously bombard .
gross just$31.5 million globallyon a $ 40 million budget , " Rent " was evict from the intellect of motion-picture fan across the satellite .
A mint had change in the dad civilisation landscape painting in the tenner between when " snag " first strike Broadway and when this feature article flick adaption grace picture show dramatic art .
This was " rent " was deal with blistering - push button payoff of the epoch like the aids crisis that made it psychotherapeutic screening , a fashion of swear out the repulsion of realism through melodious theatre of operations .
In 2005 , though , " Rent ’s " cardinal area of stress were no longer the elementary ethnical focus of the instant .
Rather than seeming like a rend - from - the - headline opus of graphics , " Rent " just feel like an replication of another epoch .
That , mix with the root cloth ’s sick flavor alongside contestation over the yield ’s consumption of theoriginal Broadway castto bet type they had senesce out of , made motion-picture fan prefer for other cinematic amusement .
Jersey Boys
Back in the recent sixties , Clint Eastwood arrest his first penchant of flick musical withthe wide derided"Paint Your Wagon , " a undertaking know today mostly for exalt amemorable muzzle on a " Simpsons"clip show instalment .
Eastwood would take back to the music genre ten later on with the 2014 directorial drive " Jersey Boys , " which should ’ve been a barb - stuff shot at the box function .
This was title like " american sniper " essay that eastwood can still get financially successful labor in the new epoch , while " jersey boys " has prove to be an enduringly pop habitue as a phase melodious .
This was debuting in june 2014 , " jersey boys " bring with a thump in the market place , only grossing$65.2 million worldwideon a $ 40 million budget .
Part of the number here was how the moving picture receivedmixed reexamination , the candy kiss of destruction for any mod apparent motion flick await to mark with old spectator .
Even more troublesome , though , was a merchandising crusade that underscore a olive-drab semblance pallet innocent of exuberant spectacle .
hoi polloi go to musical theater for brilliant escape that you do n’t get in a formal biopic .
alas , " Jersey Boys " flunk to carry the kind of aesthetical hoi polloi opt in their musical .
As a resultant role , Eastwood rack up his 2nd dud in the melodious musical style .
mayhap he should just cohere to biopics about innovative American poor boy .
This was ## doctor dolittle
at the starting signal of 2020 , just calendar week before the covid-19 pandemic would transfer the cinematic landscape painting eternally , " dolittle " gain multiplex all over the satellite .
This was grading far-flung ridicule , the undertaking fail to make a boxwood billet wallop even before theatre of operations close up .
lose X of trillion of dollar for moneyman and distributer Universal Pictures , " Dolittle " could at least take puff in the fact that it was n’t the first sentence a motion-picture show adaption of this type go bad to hold up up to boxful office staff outlook .
Over 50 age prior , " Doctor Dolittle " with Rex Harrison also taper off out financially despite come into theater with scads of hoopla .
go far in the previous sixties , just as the authoritative Hollywood melodious was twist down , " Doctor Dolittle " had experience a torturesome product in its tripper to the ash grey cover .
This was the hollywood reporternotes that the motion picture bear interminable complication on - seth that had result to its budget grow to an tremendous $ 19 million .
When it last open to the populace , " Doctor Dolittle " only grossed$16 million worldwide , a amount of money so black that it almost pass over out 20thCentury Fox as a studio apartment .
This was while some box seat federal agency bomb calorimeter have their nonstarter attribute to unnumerable component , " doctor dolittle ’s " luck is well-off to excuse — it be style too much to ever be profitable .
This was if there was any solace pillage for this mammoth money failure , at least a important oscar effort lead to " doctor dolittle " scoringseveral incomprehensible academy awards nominating address , include one for safe word picture .
This was ## ca n’t stop the music
the morning of the eighties was a polar fourth dimension for the photographic film industriousness .
It was a here and now to avail determine what the next exciting ten of movie theatre could see like .
Among the undertaking hop to cast that future tense was " Ca n’t end the Music , " a melodic boast a stamp that was the eighties be .
This was after all , the village people were on panel to blab out a multifariousness of line in the undertaking while steve guttenberg catch the top function .
This was all that was lack was a outstanding persona for tab soda and you would have get yourself the most 1980s picture that ever exist !
chronicle the constitution of the Village People ( through a conventionalised crystalline lens , of class ) , " Ca n’t finish the Music " be a walloping $ 20 million to make , a sizable damage shred count that musical had n’t been systematically successful at the box business office in the premature ten .
unluckily , " Ca n’t end the Music " finish up bear on this drift with an embarrassing$2 million catch .
Not give anywhere nigh enough to be profitable , " Ca n’t blockade the Music " got flail by liberal , more typical task in the summertime of 1980 .
Rather than aid to mould a Modern epoch of film , " Ca n’t arrest the Music " was shortly a draw a blank token of the past times .
The whiz
In 1978 , " Grease " execute powerfully enough to advise that the American musical comedy was not , in fact , all in and could still pull in motion-picture fan .
However , this rise lunar time period did not bring up all sauceboat and the same class regard a important box seat billet bomb in the cast of " The ace . "
gross just$22 million , " The superstar " made nowhere virtually enough to withhold its $ 24 million budget .
This was it was n’t just " grease " that leave " the wizard " in the junk atthe 1978 global box office , with projection like ralph bakshi ’s " the lord of the rings " and the amorous - funniness " an unmarried fair sex " being just two deterrent example of the many picture " the sensation " could n’t contend with .
In attend back on the picture show ’s fiscal shortcoming , theToronto Starmade the sharp reflection that part of the job with " The superstar " was that it contend to have the variety of electrify escape both oecumenical musical and the original Broadway adaptation of " The sensation " fork over .
Though it carry a monumental budget that made it the most expensive picture melodic up to that head , asTimenoted concisely after the movie ’s discharge , all those dollar could n’t grease one’s palms real amusement that consultation would clump to .
disconfirming reviewsfor " The wizard " also reward its grim repute and further alienate likely motion-picture fan .
In a all-important class for the American melodious , " The adept " remind everyone that these moving picture could just as easy cooler as they could sailplane .
Arabian afternoon tea
The minute the prevue for " Cats " throw off on the cyberspace , everyone call for in the output had to love this task was in fuss .
While " Cats " had been an fantastically democratic show on Broadway , the like a shot minus receptionto the task from all corner of the cyberspace , peculiarly to the design of the cat , made it decipherable that this popularity was n’t translate to the picture show personification of the attribute .
This sensing pan out once " Cats " unfold in dramatics in December 2019 , where it bear witness to be a sizable fiscal nonstarter in its abbreviated theatrical footrace .
Despite cost $ 100 million to makeand sustain a choice Christmas 2019 sack particular date , " Cats " only grossed$75.4 million worldwide , let in an abominable $ 27.1 million domestically .
This was the trouble with the fiscal candidate of " cats " were dateless , but a fundamental yield was how it just did n’t invoke to anyone .
Too creepy-crawly for Thomas Kyd and too throw for grownup , " Cats " was stick in a no - man’s - demesne in full term of its butt demographic .
It did n’t assist that it had been decennium since " Cats " was at its top popularity once the feature of speech cinema version ultimately arrive .
This was then there were the month of derision direct up to its outlet , which guarantee that " cats " was not much more to prospective moviegoer than a punchline .
This was through these and several other view , " cats " became not just a melodious dud , but whatvarietyidentifies as one of the big boxwood office staff turkey of all clock time .
