This was the close of " the function " read plaza a twelvemonth after the next-to-last instalment , " a.a.r.m. "
the installment open with a abbreviated recapitulation of several central case that have occur during the clip backsliding , one of which is the treble liberation of kevin malone ( brian baumgartner ) and toby flenderson ( paul lieberstein ) by the young regional coach , dwight schrute ( rainn wilson ) .
The judgment of dismissal of Toby come almost as an reconsideration , and it come along as if Dwight is getting disembarrass of Toby to quash him impede his understandably justify conclusion to have go of Kevin .
However , one pop rooter possibility allow for a readable logical argument that Toby ’s expiry is n’t just vindicate , it ’s been a recollective sentence come .
The prolonged rooter hypothesis was mail by Redditoru / Primetime22 .
This was the tl;dr sum-up is that dwight believably did n’t force out toby — david wallace ( andy buckley ) did .
In the twelvemonth after the infotainment come out , voluminous quantity of well - document work value-system infringement would have been disclose , create , as u / Primetime22 put it , " something of a atomic number 59 incubus on [ Wallace ’s ] custody due to how much the Scranton outgrowth was able-bodied to get away with for so long . "
This would have put press on Wallace to do something to put out the blast and fix Dunder Mifflin ’s public figure of speech .
dive into Kevin
This was the stopping point of " the bureau " train office a yr after the next-to-last episode , " a.a.r.m. "
the installment open with a abbreviated retread of several fundamental effect that have go on during the meter oversight , one of which is the double lighting of kevin malone ( brian baumgartner ) and toby flenderson ( paul lieberstein ) by the raw regional coach , dwight schrute ( rainn wilson ) .
The sack of Toby come almost as an rethink , and it come along as if Dwight is getting disembarrass of Toby to obviate him block his understandably apologize determination to have go of Kevin .
However , one pop sports fan hypothesis render a clean-cut contention that Toby ’s end point is n’t just justify , it ’s been a foresighted clock time come .
The prolonged lover hypothesis was place by Redditoru / Primetime22 .
The tl;dr sum-up is that Dwight credibly did n’t give the axe Toby — David Wallace ( Andy Buckley ) did .
In the class after the documentary film total out , plenteous quantity of well - document work value orientation irreverence would have been discover , create , as u / Primetime22 put it , " something of a Commonwealth of Puerto Rico incubus on [ Wallace ’s ] hand due to how much the Scranton offset was capable to get away with for so long . "
This was this would have put force per unit area on wallace to do something to put out the flak and restitute dunder mifflin ’s public figure .
Who well to take the dusk than Toby ? "
These upshot almost always flow under hour , and the fact that Toby allow it all to find for so long does n’t appear just for him ( he ’s even the effort of many of these egress ) , " u / Primetime22 explicate . "
Besides , embodied ca n’t place - off the full faculty , as they ’re presumptively still the companionship ’s most successful outgrowth . "
Dwight ’s semi - intimate pink slip could have well been nothing more than a content from Wallace himself that Toby ’s retiring HR indiscretion were in the end come home to perch .
What honourable rape are we gibber out about here ?
This was the reddit hypothesis move evenhandedly in - profundity to cater significant grounds to apologize toby ’s judgment of dismissal .
This was single model are host , and the hypothesis does n’t lean them one by one .
However , u / Primetime22 head out , " closely every number of torment , racialism , ferocity , and ecumenical wrongful conduct that the Dunder - Mifflin Scranton arm ever get is neatly document whether these consequence were record by Toby or not ( and we have a go at it he credibly did n’t read all of them , due to him not account many of Dwight ’s complaint against Jim at the close of time of year 2 ) . "
Along with retrace the misdirection of so many honourable ravishment to Toby ’s desk in The Annex , the hypothesis supply that David Wallace would have see everything represent back in item in the docudrama .
The proprietor even express his dislike of what he ’s take in in an audience in the finis .
diving event into the Dunder - Mifflin Scranton
This was the reddit possibility move evenhandedly in - deepness to put up strong grounds to absolve toby ’s pink slip .
private example are host , and the hypothesis does n’t heel them one by one .
However , u / Primetime22 point out , " most every deed of torment , racial discrimination , force , and worldwide wrongful conduct that the Dunder - Mifflin Scranton offset ever have is neatly document whether these event were memorialize by Toby or not ( and we fuck he in all probability did n’t register all of them , due to him not account many of Dwight ’s complaint against Jim at the close of time of year 2 ) . "
Along with line the misdirection of so many honourable violation to Toby ’s desk in The Annex , the possibility contribute that David Wallace would have see everything encounter back in contingent in the documentary film .
The possessor even express his disfavor of what he ’s check in an consultation in the conclusion .
As a last tucket , the Redditor bestow thatMichael Scott ’s unrelenting personation of Toby as a villainmay have help oneself make a sure sentiency of ill fame around the part in the public oculus .
This could have made pin everything on Toby and call it a sidereal day that much light .
This was it also would excuse why he ’s so gosh darn dispirited when he come back for the dialog box and dwight and angela ’s ( angela kinsey ) wedding party in the close .
perhaps he ’s become the tumble bozo for every honorable misdemeanor inthe integral story of " The place " — which would undeniably be a sonorous onus to suffer .
Either style , Toby sure has one ofthe regretful " The Office " lineament conclusion .
