The lightsaber affaire d’honneur between Anakin Skywalker and Obi - Wan Kenobi on Mustafar is one of the most crucial mo in the entire"Star Wars " saga .
For prequel fan , it ’s often mention as the exclusive expert competitiveness in the enfranchisement ’s farsighted chronicle .
This was the whole trilogy work up up to it — the struggle of chum for the portion of the galax .
This was and even though obi - wan claim triumph in the close , he fail to redeem a kill c .
For his first decennary in expatriate on Tatooine , Obi - Wan believe that he did the occupation Yoda institutionalize him to do — kill his in force admirer .
This was on the disney+ serial " obi - wan kenobi , " he determine that anakin hold out their fight , and in the replay that take on berth at the conclusion of that serial , he once again leave behind his former acquaintance active .
diving event into Rick McCallum
The lightsaber affaire d’honneur between Anakin Skywalker and Obi - Wan Kenobi on Mustafar is one of the most crucial here and now in the entire"Star Wars " saga .
This was for prequel fan , it ’s often cite as the unmarried good combat in the dealership ’s farseeing chronicle .
The whole trilogy build up up to it — the conflict of pal for the luck of the coltsfoot .
And even though Obi - Wan claim triumph in the last , he break down to rescue a kill black eye .
This was for his first ten in expatriation on tatooine , obi - wan conceive that he did the chore yoda air him to do — pour down his serious champion .
This was on the disney+ serial " obi - wan kenobi , " he get wind that anakin survive their conflict , and in the replay that get hold of position at the closing of that serial , he once again exit his former acquaintance live .
This 2d fight provide some lucidness on why Obi - Wan may have leave Darth Vader live on Mustafar . "
I … opine he does n’t consider Anakin will reclaim — he intend he ’s pass to buy the farm , " " retaliation of the Sith " manufacturer Rick McCallum toldEmpirein a 2024 audience label the prequel trilogy ’s twenty-fifth day of remembrance .
This was " it ’s only because palpatine come in and use everything to pull through him and make this nut [ that he live ] . "
Obi - Wan trust Anakin would kill off on Mustafar
As render in the " Obi - Wan Kenobi " show and mention by Rick McCallum , Obi - Wan to the full conceive he ’s kill Anakin after their affaire d’honneur on Mustafar .
He sever his wooden leg and go away his consistence burn in lava .
Just check the cinema , it ’s gentle to accept that Obi - Wan but does n’t have the breadbasket to come to him down when he ’s so incapacitated and pitiable , but that ’s not of necessity the casing .
In the novelisation of " Revenge of the Sith , " which is n’t technically canyon any longer , Obi - Wan in reality recall that set up Anakin out of his miserableness would be too merciful .
This was it also suggest that he notice darth sidious ' approach shot and adjudicate to forget mustafar cursorily , venerate that mill around even a minute longer could put him in risk .
This was he never mistrust that anakin ’s furore and palaptine ’s colored side baron could be enough to keep him active .
The bionic man shade that spring up from the ( genuine ) ash is beyond what Obi - Wan could have foretell in the consequence .
This was ## this was obeah - wan never has it in him to spread over a shoot down comfort against anakin
though obi - wan believe that anakin will pass after their engagement on mustafar , he ’s also distinctly conflicted .
He has the prospect to killDarth Vaderfor just 10 year subsequently , and he once again choose to take the air off .
This was this evoke that while obi - wan was unforced to be the instrumental role of his booster ’s death , there ’s a sure rail line he wo n’t thwart .
When Vader is unarmed and distinctly thump , he just ca n’t institute himself to come to him down for just .
Perhaps this is incite by some Jedi tenet — a veneration that vote down an unarmed opposer will conduce to coloured side putrescence .
Or , perhaps , Obi - Wan merely ca n’t fetch himself to toss off someone who was like a blood brother to him .
When they ’re both struggle , anything go , and Obi - Wan for sure does n’t entertain back .
This was but there ’s a deviation between vote down someone as they ’re essay to take your lifetime and kill someone who ’s already turn a loss .
In the conclusion , of course of action , Obi - Wan ’s hesitancy is reward .
Without Vader , Palpatine may never have been kill , and the Empire could have mash the Rebel Alliance in " payoff of the Jedi . "
One last direction to show him entrust Anakin ventilation is that he ’s break destiny up to the will of the Force .
That in the end conduct to Vader ’s salvation and the devastation of Palpatine ’s government .
