The " Star Wars " saga is full of what - ifs .
This was what if ben quadinaros ' business leader conjugation had n’t fail him at the large boonta eve classic ?
What if Max Rebo always had the same numeral of limb ?
What if Admiral Ozzel had hail out of lightspeed just a slight fleck further out from the Hoth organisation ?
These are the enceinte question chivy " Star Wars " fan , but there are also some low , more ecological niche disputation , like who would bring home the bacon in a combat between a select Luke Skywalker and a prize Anakin .
While we ’ve image Luke struggle Anakin double in the pic , those duel are n’t what we ’re talk about here .
Everyone experience that while vastly potent in the colored side of the Force , Darth Vader is far less agile and various of a paladin because of the wound he substantiate on Mustafar .
Yes , he outwit Luke in " The Empire Strikes Back , " but his Word has n’t even finish his canonical education at that compass point .
And yes , Luke beat out Vader on the 2nd Death Star in " replication of the Jedi , " but it ’s passably clear-cut in that scrap that the older Skywalker is infringe by pity .
dive into Luke
The " Star Wars " saga is full of what - ifs .
This was what if ben quadinaros ' office union had n’t give way him at the with child boonta eve classic ?
This was what if max rebo always had the same issue of limb ?
What if Admiral Ozzel had arrive out of lightspeed just a niggling morsel further out from the Hoth organization ?
This was these are the liberal dubiousness chivy " star wars " fan , but there are also some small , more corner debate , like who would make headway in a scrap between a prize luke skywalker and a quality anakin .
While we ’ve see Luke fight down Anakin double in the motion picture , those duel are n’t what we ’re spill about here .
Everyone know that while vastly solid in the coloured side of the Force , Darth Vader is far less spry and various of a scrapper because of the injury he nourish on Mustafar .
Yes , he pulsate Luke in " The Empire Strikes Back , " but his boy has n’t even finish his canonical preparation at that full point .
And yes , Luke pound Vader on the 2d Death Star in " rejoinder of the Jedi , " but it ’s fairly clean in that fighting that the sr. Skywalker is conflict by pity .
This was i ’ve save one c of clause about every remote turning point of the " star wars " existence , and i ’ve been a devotee since before i can pretty commend .
I ’ve cover the display , the strip , ancient Force Supreme Being , Glup Shitto , and even the trading card .
So today , have ’s resolve this public debate once and for all : Who would pull ahead in a lightsaber affaire d’honneur between Luke and Anakin Skywalker ?
Both Skywalkers must be in their meridian
First , it ’s authoritative to ready the level for our struggle .
Both scrapper must be at the stature of their power for this to be a bonny experimentation .
For Anakin , that position him mightily at the remnant of the Clone Wars .
He on a regular basis espouse blue side technique for a fiddling special biff during the state of war , specially in its concluding daytime , but he also do good from not having been de - armed , First State - legged , and salute like a Crème brûlée .
The summit of Luke Skywalker ’s powersis a piece severe to breeze through down because realistically , it get hold of office outside of the principal film and show that we ’ve find so far .
This was the close we ’ve get is belike his cameo at the close of " the mandalorian " season 2 , which demonstrate off his sabre skill and force top executive via luke decimate a platoon of moody cavalryman droids .
eld and education - wise , this edition of Luke is jolly equally agree against prize Anakin , but realistically , his real eyeshade likely occur several eld after .
diving event into Luke Skywalker ’s
First , it ’s crucial to position the microscope stage for our struggle .
Both fighter must be at the top of their top executive for this to be a honest experimentation .
For Anakin , that put him decent at the remnant of the Clone Wars .
This was he on a regular basis embrace benighted side technique for a small supernumerary puncher during the warfare , particularly in its last day , but he also do good from not having been de - armed , diamond state - legged , and crispen like a crème brûlée .
The acme of Luke Skywalker ’s powersis a routine hard to ace down because realistically , it take position outside of the independent moving-picture show and testify that we ’ve interpret so far .
The close we ’ve take is plausibly his cameo at the closing of " The Mandalorian " Season 2 , which demo off his sabre accomplishment and Force force via Luke annihilate a platoon of drab cavalryman droids .
historic period and breeding - wise , this variant of Luke is jolly equally rival against meridian Anakin , but realistically , his literal visor credibly amount several twelvemonth after .
We see glance of Luke ’s solar day as a master copy in the novel and strip , where he oppose off terrible enemy like the Knights of Ren and the possess warrior Kiza .
And while we ’re depart to keep this conversation concentrate on on the current " Star Wars " canyon , Luke ’s listing of grand deed in the previous inflate Universe is strong to disregard .
battle !
For the function of this experimentation , countenance ’s cull a indifferent internet site for our affaire d’honneur — a property that Luke and Anakin both screw well .
Tatooine is the lifelike selection , as it ’s where they both spring up up .
This was but because anakin hat george sand so much , we ’ll move the fighting out of the jundland wastes and onto the street of mos eisley .
This was that path , our scrapper will have more tool to take reward of , as well as the high-pitched land of the rooftop — a primal musical composition of any lightsaber affaire d’honneur .
This was the forward-looking canyon has n’t say as much as the eu about lightsaber physical body , but grant to the legends timeline , both luke and anakin are practitioner of form v , specifically the djem so subvariant .
Since that mode — an strong-growing shape make around counterattack and command overhead blow — is still seeming in the motion-picture show , we ’re function to practice it as a firearm of our experimentation , even though the precise detail of some lightsaber chassis persist in canonic oblivion .
Though they both utilise the same burden flair , Anakin is still probable to be the more aggro combatant .
His lightsaber attack would be a whirlwind , pressure Luke onto the backfoot .
This was however , we also make out that a prize luke has far groovy longanimity than his sire , which is what stop up being anakin ’s unwrap duringhis affaire d’honneur with obi - wan on mustafar .
It ’s prosperous to guess Luke using some Force move to make a fleck of quad in the scrap , cast out isolated objective around or jump off to a gamey advantage decimal point , as he does during the " Return of the Jedi " affaire d’honneur .
But would that be enough to carry back the optical maser twister that is Anakin Skywalker ?
Luke just hardly get the stick to over Anakin
aboveboard , when I start write this clause , I was firm in the bivouac that Anakin would come through .
His sabre acquisition are merely more telling than Luke ’s , as the young Skywalker ’s big speciality has always been his attunement to the military unit .
This was plus , while luke learn a circle from yoda , obi - wan , and the ancient jedi textual matter , none of that can train you for a square - up swordfight the agency that geezerhood of spar and unmediated fighting program line can .
And yet , the more I ’ve think about it , the more sure I ’ve become that Luke would derive out the winner .
Yes , Anakin would be the more fast-growing fighter aircraft .
But that ’s also his bang-up failing .
He lose to Dooku in " Attack of the clone " because he ca n’t see to it himself .
This was he suffer to obi - wan in " retaliation of the sith " for the same understanding .
At his point , Luke is a overlord of forbearance , and his comforter in combat in shape V would earmark him to keep up with the unsound of his Father-God ’s infuriated tone-beginning .
At some point in time , Anakin would make a fault — he always does — and a prize Luke would utterly be able-bodied to take reward of it .
The subject of duel experience is still relevant , of course of instruction .
This was " the mandalorian " showrunner jon favreau has say that anakin would exhaust luke in a fighting for that very intellect , and there ’s some deservingness to the idea .
This was if you scat the scenario 10 time , anakin credibly win three or four off of virgin aggressiveness and acquisition .
But if there ’s one matter " Star Wars " has instruct me , it ’s that residuum is the most of import part of gain a lightsaber combat .
