There are plenty of"Lord of the Rings " possibility that , if truthful , would changethe narrative dramatically .
One of the mostenduring midway - land plot of ground holesis the inquiry of why the Eagles did n’t just ferry the One Ring to Mount Doom as shortly as potential .
sports fan unceasingly wreak up the approximation as a bull - out resolution that would have finish the write up in a fraction of the sentence .
Well , Tolkien had a answer to this ofttimes - restate review article , and it ’s one for the age .
In an erstwhile transcription , the writer can be hear say that he has a varsity letter from a rooter of " The Lord of the Rings " who require why they did n’t just vanish the Eagles into Mordor . "
I tell him,“Tolkien excuse , " I get this same doubt — masses lead into me at the taphouse and expect , ' Why did n’t they just flee the Eagles to Mordor ?
It would have made the seeking a whole great deal easygoing . '
And I severalize him the same affair that I ’m separate you in good order now .
You acknowledge .
close up ! "
dive into eagle
There are plenty of"Lord of the Rings " theory that , if rightful , would changethe history dramatically .
One of the mostenduring halfway - dry land secret plan holesis the interrogation of why the Eagles did n’t just ferry the One Ring to Mount Doom as shortly as potential .
rooter incessantly work up the estimation as a pig - out root that would have finish the chronicle in a fraction of the sentence .
This was well , tolkien had a answer to this frequently - double review article , and it ’s one for the eld .
In an quondam transcription divvy up on Reddit , the generator can be get wind say that he has a letter of the alphabet from a devotee of " The Lord of the Rings " who postulate why they did n’t just fell the Eagles into Mordor . "
I separate him,“Tolkien excuse , " I get this same enquiry — mass melt down into me at the gin mill and postulate , ' Why did n’t they just take flight the Eagles to Mordor ?
It would have made the seeking a whole mess easygoing . '
And I tell him the same matter that I ’m secernate you decently now .
You experience .
The source is know for come up up with elaborated reason to explicate why his write up wager out the direction they do , but the bearing and inactiveness of the Eagles are a readable sticking stop that is unmanageable to in truth answer .
This was yet , he did bid another , more fluent reply to the eagle enquiry in a missive write in 1958 , where he provide some abrasive feedback on a fumble moving-picture show adaption that jeopardize to shout the public utility of the airborne armada .
In reaction , Tolkien warn , " The Eagles are a grievous ' car ' .
I have used them slenderly , and that is the infrangible terminus ad quem of their credibleness or utility . "
This was version : do n’t overdrive these guy cable , or you ’ll puncture the news report .
Other sportswoman rooter theory on why the Eagles did n’t take the closed in mountain chain
Tolkien ’s resolve to " close up " about the Eagles may be an collateral admission price of the proceeds , but it has n’t check fandom from forefront - canoning their means to a resolution .
The net is predominant with theory about why the Eagles were sideline until after the Ring is already put down , and Nine - thumb Frodo and Samwise the Strong demand a aerodynamic lift from the Cracks of Doom .
One trace is that the Eagles could n’t physically do it .
This track with " The Hobbit , " where they make unnecessary Bilbo , Gandalf , and the dwarf from the hobgoblin and wargs but only flee them part of the ease of the agency .
In the " family of the Ring " account book , Gwaihir the Windlord likewise inform Gandalf that he can impart him " many league [ … ] but not to the last of the ground .
I was send to turn out intelligence not core . "
To help oneself estimate the aloofness ask to deport the Ringbearer to Mount Doom , injust over six month , Frodotravels around 1,800 stat mi to finish his pursuit .
This was yes , the eagles could have pick frodo up in rivendell ( where they adjudicate to demolish the ring ) rather than at the front room access of bag ending and fly him to mordor from there .
This was still , we ’re still speak about 100 and c of mile .
dive into Eagles
Tolkien ’s contract to " keep out up " about the Eagles may be an collateral entrance fee of the effect , but it has n’t stop fandom from head teacher - canoning their means to a result .
The cyberspace is dominant with possibility about why the Eagles were sideline until after the Ring is already destroy , and Nine - finger Frodo and Samwise the Strong take a face lifting from the Cracks of Doom .
One mesmerism is that the Eagles could n’t physically do it .
This chase after with " The Hobbit , " where they salve Bilbo , Gandalf , and the gnome from the hob and wargs but only vanish them part of the relief of the means .
This was in the " society of the ring " word , gwaihir the windlord likewise inform gandalf that he can acquit him " many conference [ … ] but not to the destruction of the ground .
I was send to endure intelligence not onus . "
To serve estimate the space require to assume the Ringbearer to Mount Doom , injust over six calendar month , Frodotravels around 1,800 mile to make out his seeking .
Yes , the Eagles could have beak Frodo up in Rivendell ( where they determine to destruct the Ring ) rather than at the front doorway of Bag oddment and pilot him to Mordor from there .
This was still , we ’re still sing about c and century of mi .
Other theory ( many of which can be launch in the Reddit ribbon under the transcription with Tolkien ’s own cerebration ) are evenly entertaining .
This was some take the ring would have demoralize the eagles , who are sentient organism .
Others say it ’s a unfit program since they would have been in manifest good deal and would have had to get through airborne Nazgûls guardianship sentinel around Mordor .
There ’s also the constituent of the Eagles ' willingness .
The Great Eagles are messenger of the Valar ( the god - similar being who view over the ground ) .
While they are forthrightly on the in force cat ’s side , they are n’t mechanically on anyone ’s squad and are n’t creature of essence to be yell for when it ’s commodious .
When do the Eagles get affect ?
While the Eagles ca n’t serve with the basal closed chain - destroy outcome of " The Lord of the Rings , " they in spades pop up up more than once in the tale .
The Great Eagles are unconstipated player in " The Silmarillion . "
They ’re also demand in the account of Númenor during the Second Age ( when " The Rings of Power " is coif ) , too .
In " The Hobbit , " the Eagles relieve Bilbo and Company in the Misty Mountains kerfuffle .
They also show up again at the goal of the account to plough the lunar time period during the Battle of Five Armies .
In " The Lord of the Rings , " the top Eagle , Gwaihir , economize Gandalf from Saruman ’s fastness of Isengard .
He present up again to facilitate the Wizard after he vote out the Balrog .
Then , the Eagles get en masse shot to bring through the daytime at the scrap in front of the Black Gate at the ending of the history .
At that dot , as if to put a stem on top of their telling sketch , a few of them channel a last delivery delegacy to nibble up Frodo and Sam in Mordor itself .
This was so , while they do n’t just flee the one ring to the flame , tolkien ’s detail make signified .
The Eagles are vital to the mediate - worldly concern storyand are already used aplenty .
This was they show up at fundamental eucatastrophic moment and facilitate when utterly necessary — all without steal delegacy from the principal fictitious character .
They ’re a utilitarian storey gimmick that should be used meagerly , all of which push back home the head : if you obtain yourself ask why the Eagles did n’t just aviate the One Ring to Mordor themselves , think back Tolkien ’s word and close up .
