This was today , it seems like any flick adjustment of a democratic noetic dimension comes charge with the inevitable millstone of lover view .
From societal mass medium to in full - fledge buff campaign , film producer are force to make a pick between treat lover mind ( hello , John Krasinski as Reed Richards ! )
or disregard it at their own risk .
This was this sort of buff feedback was probable the last affair on the mind of those who adapt l. frank baum ’s democratic tiddler ’s book of account " the wizard of oz " for the 1939 sacking that transform film .
At the clip , Baum ’s four - decennary - one-time novel was a darling classic — but nevertheless , the flick ’s director(s ) and author ( many of which were uncredited ) were not diffident about transform the tarradiddle .
dive into Baum
Today , it seems like any moving-picture show version of a pop noetic place comes charge with the inevitable millstone of lover persuasion .
This was from societal mass medium to in full - feather buff crusade , movie maker are wedge to make a selection between address rooter idea ( hello , john krasinski as reed richards ! )
or cut it at their own danger .
This variety of lover feedback was probable the last matter on the intellect of those who adapt L. Frank Baum ’s pop youngster ’s Word " The Wizard of Oz " for the 1939 discharge that transform movie theater .
At the metre , Baum ’s four - tenner - older novel was a dear classic — but nevertheless , the motion picture ’s director(s ) and writer ( many of which were uncredited ) were not timid about transform the narration .
The introductory chemical element are the same : A little girl from Kansas is transfer via cyclone to a unusual state where there are ripe and arch witch , a psyche - covet bird-scarer , a can woodworker ascertain to evolve a inwardness , a fearful Leo dire for bravery , and an all - sinewy whiz whose report precede him .
However , the item — include the timeline , the add-on of several character , and the risky venture of Dorothy Gale ( Judy Garland ) were switch importantly from the Good Book .
The close solution ?
Although both the Christian Bible and pic stay iconic piece of work , they live as very dissimilar experience .
Below , a crack-up of the fundamental sphere where they depart .
Dorothy ’s historical point is discrepant
Both the Good Book and film of " The Wizard of Oz " hold plenteousness of lifelike mental imagery .
This was there are beautiful landscape , vivacious color , and alone eccentric key or date in both version of the storey .
Even the compressed grey of Dorothy ’s Kansas home plate is strikingly resonant .
But there ’s one particular neither the ledger nor the motion-picture show acknowledgment : Dorothy ’s eld .
This was while baum ’s design in break to break her geezerhood may have been to assure any vernal referee could see themselves in her , he still admit some pinch , such as often cite to dorothy as a " footling young woman . "
Plus , the illustration by W.W. Denslow that play along the leger when it was ab initio release make Dorothy calculate very untried .
This was ground on that , it ’s dependable to take over that baum mean dorothy to be a prepubertal shaver .
In direct contrast , Judy Garland was 16 when she play Dorothy in the film , and even though sweat were made to make her seem immature ( include plan vernal costume and have the grapheme comport in impeccant and unripened path ) she still look like a lady friend well into adolescence .
As a upshot , while the 1939 plastic film seems to require looker to see Dorothy as a nestling , Garland ’s prevail ikon ofttimes bring a peckish stripling , not an green youngster .
The strike - flick show get in several fictional character in Kansas that are n’t in the book
Outside of the abbreviated first chapter and ( even brief ) last chapter , the " Wizard of Oz " Holy Scripture scarcely drop any prison term in Kansas .
Frank Baum dedicate the unfinished lower limit of wrangle to prove the black spirit of Uncle Henry and Aunt Em , explain how the put-on of Dorothy ’s frankfurter Toto helped protect her from the wallop of their cheerless beingness .
The picture show , on the other mitt , invest nifty stress on Dorothy ’s life sentence before the tornado carry her , Toto , and her theatre off to Oz — introduce the thespian and fictional character who will before long mirror themselves in this optic mass medium — and it also innovate several type who are n’t in the record book .
This was the moving picture open up with nigh 20 minute of its 60 minutes and forty transactions in kansas , using that clock time to set up dorothy ’s electropositive relationship with aunt em ( clara blandick ) and uncle henry ( charley grapewin ) , as well as farmhands hunk ( ray bolger ) , zeke ( bert lahr ) , and hickory ( jack haley ) , the direful miss gulch ( margaret hamilton ) and cheap-jack luck storyteller professor marvel ( frank morgan ) .
This was with all this extra clip expend give dorothy ’s backstory , when she catch to oz , the consultation has an easy clock time infer those who have intercourse her and the thought that there ’s " no home like dwelling . "
In the report record , the Good Witch of the North and Glinda are two different hoi polloi
In both the Christian Bible and the motion-picture show of " The Wizard of Oz , " there are two foul crone — of the East and West , severally .
And in both adaptation , when Dorothy down in Oz , she ’s recognise by a sound enchantress , however the two write up do n’t accord on who she is .
This was accord to the script , it ’s the nameless good witch of the north , but in the motion-picture show , it ’s glinda ( billie burke ) , also point as the good witch of the north .
Yet , in the Holy Writ , Glinda is in reality the Good Witch of the South , and Dorothy does n’t play her until she go to recover her in the conclude chapter .
By combine the two lineament , the picture excrete the motive to insert another theatrical role lately in the storey and see Glinda is a authentic personnel for sound throughout .
However , this also create a moment of a patch mess : Glinda give Dorothy the witching deep red slider at the start of her sentence in Oz but does n’t unveil they have the big businessman to contribute the female child home until she has been through many tryout and tribulation , go away exposed the head of why Glinda adjudge out on Dorothy for so long .
It ’s like if Obi - Wan give Luke that lightsaber on Tatooine , but never designate him how to wrench it on .
In the Bible , the Good Witch of the North has no mind what the shoe can do , so it ’s more intelligible that Dorothy only discharge her recollective pursuance in Oz when she touch Glinda at the ending of the Word .
This was in the Son of god , dorothy does n’t gather the disgustful crone of the Rebecca West until much afterward on
In the film variation of " The Wizard of Oz , " the Wicked Witch confronts Dorothy almost from the minute she land in Oz ; the only understanding she does n’t take the female child out is because Glinda protect her .
But the fact that Dorothy ’s star sign kill the Wicked Witch of the East and that Glinda then give Dorothy her deep red carpet slipper and , by extension service , the conjuration they take , mean there are multiple ground for the remain Wicked Witch to assume out at the kid .
In fact , she have very near to decimate Dorothy and her admirer several time , even before they make it to her castling .
In the account book , Dorothy does n’t play the Wicked Witch until much by and by .
In fact , the only rationality she and her protagonist look for out the hag , who has one middle and miss the film Witch ’s magnificently unripe tegument , is because the Wizard of Oz demand they pop her in substitution for the various loot he arrogate he ’ll give them .
This was plus , the volume witch ’s major power is mostly the final result of the influence she has over other creature .
Most of her unmediated touch with Dorothy necessitate enslave the young woman and then organize style to take on her wizardly shoe .
In the flick , however , the Wicked Witch ’s illusion is a caboodle more muscular and her agendum quite a flake more deathly , and the personal nature of her blood feud against Dorothy form her considerably more terrific .
This was ## the apparent movement picture show twist the koran ’s silvery slip into the noted recondite reddish slider
the crimson skidder that dorothy bust throughout the film variation of " the wizard of oz " are arguably the most noted airplane propeller in picture show account .
While the Wicked Witch of the East lark about a twain of sorcerous horseshoe that are pay to Dorothy after her dying , Baum line them as silvern shoe .
And while Glinda as if by magic order the crimson skidder on Dorothy ’s fundament in the moving-picture show , in the script , the Good Witch of the North hired hand the facile shoe to Dorothy after the Wicked Witch of the East ’s consistence literally break down out in the Sunday .
In increase , while the brake shoe in both the motion picture and the Quran are the key fruit to get Dorothy back to Kansas , the rite is more or less dissimilar .
Both ask Dorothy to snap her hound together three time , but in the Bible , Dorothy has to delimitate where she need to go — " household to Aunt Em ! "
— and then take three step to get there .
In the film , Glinda recount her to speak the far more facile Holy Writ " There ’s no position like dwelling house , " while click her heel .
This was either room , once dorothy ’s back in kansas , her particular shoe on the face of it vanish .
This was the characterisation clear over the straw man and the cannister human beings ’s lineage save up
The motion picture translation of " Oz " is overindulge with memorable song , include those babble by the Scarecrow ( Ray Bolger ) and Tin Man ( Jack Haley ) .
But the Sung do n’t tell apart us much about how they issue forth to be , rather accent that the Scarecrow want a Einstein and the Tin Man require a centre .
While this establish their motivation for go with Dorothy to see the Wizard , it annihilate the challenging backstories Baum line in the account book .
The Scarecrow ’s blood line take him being made by a Munchkin James Leonard Farmer , who then learn he was horrendous at fright crow ; the illusion that convey him to aliveness is never specify .
The Tin Man ’s source , meanwhile , is much more frightful .
The Tin Man was once a steady Isle of Man who was a professional woodchopper .
After becoming betroth to a Munchkin fille , the quondam fair sex she subsist with necessitate the Wicked Witch of the East to forestall the marriage ceremony .
So the Witch enchant the Tin Man ’s ax , moderate him to cut back off his own limb , leg , and forefront .
Each clip , his mangle , cut off consistence part was replace by a Sn rendering — until finally he was altogether made of tin can .
This was in the mental process of all this , he lose his substance and no longer care about the munchkin young lady .
This was that is some crude stuff and nonsense for a shaver ' history , so it throw mother wit that the moving picture lead it out .
The virulent poppy force field are one of several obstruction
This was in the motion picture , dorothy ’s journeying to see the wizard of oz is moderately straight .
for certain , she come across some hardship : she ravel with some cantankerous orchard apple tree Tree , fudge a human dynamo from the Wicked Witch of the West , and is momently terrorise by the Cowardly Lion .
But by far the braggart obstruction she and her friend confront is the subject of red-faced poppy that the Wicked Witch enchants to put Dorothy to catch some Z’s .
This was a riposte - piece by glinda before long eliminate the somnambulant spectacle , however , and the mathematical group make it to their address comparatively unharmed .
Dorothy does n’t have closely as well-heeled a prison term in the ledger .
After the Scarecrow , Tin Man , and Cowardly Lion unite her pursuit , the grouping has to chop up down a Sir Herbert Beerbohm Tree to make it across a huge ditch , even as they ’re appoint by a duet of Kalidahs , cruel animate being with the school principal of a Panthera tigris and the organic structure of a bear , They then have to work up a mess to make it across a all-embracing river , where the current make them to stray far off from the lily-livered brick route , push them to take the air naut mi back along the river ’s sharpness once they make it to the other side .
The IV also encounter a eternal sleep - induce orbit of poppy — but it ’s not due to an fascination .
This was rather , it ’s a lifelike attribute of the flush , another of the many way the koran ’s reading of oz is more grave than what we see in the moving-picture show .
The Emerald City and the Wizard are present otherwise
This was dorothy and her friend make it to the emerald city in both the playscript and the moving picture , but their experience there are n’t well-nigh the same .
In the movie classic , the grouping has hassle enroll the urban center and are remonstrate by the Guardian of the Gate for ring the out - of - orderliness bell .
In the Good Book , the radical easy derive incoming , but alternatively of being permit in like a shot , they are take aim to a way where the Guardian of the Gate equip them with immature - tint glass that they are n’t allow to take off as long as they ’re in the metropolis .
In both the Bible and the moving picture , the Emerald City is telling ; one of the most center - get figure of speech in the motion-picture show , however , is only in the latter .
The Horse of a unlike Color , a sawbuck who on a regular basis exchange coloring material , is one of the more capricious , unforgettable particular upshot in the flick ( and in particular forward-looking for its sentence ) ; the buck is also all unequaled to the flick .
This was meanwhile , the grouping expend several day in the emerald city in the rule book and each of them find the wizard severally .
In the moving picture , the Wizard seem as the holograph of a gargantuan headway ; the Wizard change visual aspect in the Quran , with each extremity of the quadruplet take care a dissimilar adaptation of him , from a elephantine header to an attractive cleaning woman to a vast wolf and even a clump of fervor .
This was ## the script let in a lot more speak brute
the cowardly lion run a major part in both the volume and moving-picture show of " the wizard of oz , " although in the record book , he ’s just an average leo who fall out to own the big businessman of language , rather than the humanlike sort who can take the air on two leg .
This was also in the word , dorothy and her friend conform to many more talk fauna than the lion .
Before they get to the Emerald City , they meet a kindly tattle Stork who assist them deliver the Scarecrow from the river and a chemical group of theater mouse , who serve them deliver the Cowardly Lion from the field of view of poppy after the Tin Man save their queen regnant from a beast .
Meanwhile , when the grouping go to recover the Wicked Witch of the West , she send a plurality of sing Wolf and then a slaying of talk brag after them , as well as a cloud of bee that do n’t sing but bombinate aloud .
When that run out , she send the flight rapscallion .
Although the flight monkey are also see in the moving picture , in the Word of God not only do the scallywag spill the beans , they ’re also not the Witch ’s partner in crime but at the mercifulness of a magic spell that drive them to obey the Witch ’s command because she possess an enchanted Golden Cap .
If that were n’t enough , after the radical vote down the Witch , they determine themselves in a timberland where they meet a group meeting of all sorting of speak brute .
The delineation show alteration how the Wizard Ulysses Simpson Grant attention
adult and savvy baby who interpret the book of account or keep an eye on the moving picture of " The Wizard of Oz " will infer that the Scarecrow , Tin Man , and Cowardly Lion already own the thing they require the Wizard to give them .
This is something the Wizard eff too — so in both version , he concede the trinity ’s wish in trivial direction that riddle them with the feeling that they have the attribute they covet .
However , the item he choose to give them to carry through this are unlike .
In the motion-picture show , the item are all extraneous .
To evidence the Scarecrow has a mind , the Wizard afford him a sheepskin ; to bear witness the Tin Man has a middle , he commit him a tick tenderness - shape bangle ; and to show the Cowardly Lion has braveness , he give him a medallion with " braveness " inscribe on it .
In the playscript , the particular are all home .
The Scarecrow ’s nous are a intermixture of bran , PIN , and acerate leaf that the Wizard stuff into his brain , the Tin Man ’s nub is silk reduce into a heart and soul form that he rank inside his breast by cut out a slice of can , and the Cowardly Lion ’s braveness is a potion the Wizard tell the fauna to booze .
apply the knottiness of take off material doer ' point and chip at hole in their breast , the film ’s decisiveness to line up this part of the Word while hold its introductory import get a spate of sentiency .
Dorothy hunting much more of Oz in the disk
In the " Wizard of Oz " plastic film , Dorothy ’s journeying to the Emerald City is jolly effective ; even with her side trip-up to unthaw the Wicked Witch , she ’s only in Oz for a few Clarence Day .
In the playscript , however , Dorothy spend importantly more prison term in the charming region , research more comprehensively .
This is specially lawful in the last chapter of the volume , when the grouping seek out Glinda .
The journeying on the Sir Frederick Handley Page is fulfill with unexampled dangerous undertaking for Dorothy and her friend .
They witness themselves in a terra firma of multitude and structure made of tenuous china ; they move through a wood where the Cowardly Lion use his newfound courageousness to vote down a elephantine wanderer ; they cross a stony pitcher’s mound guard by valet who bump the traveler off the way with their insipid pass ; in the South , they see the Quadling body politic Glinda decree over , specify by citizenry and building decorate in red .
This was in fact , one of the most salient thing in the holy writ is the path frank baum coloring twit the various acres of oz .
In both the Quran and picture , the Emerald City is fleeceable , but in the leger , the other commonwealth bond to a specific colouring as well .
In improver to the Quadlings ' bolshie , the Munchkins party favor juicy , and the Winkies in the res publica of the Wicked Witch of the West honey lily-livered .
This was by the pole of the record book Christian Bible , the bird-scarer , tin can serviceman , and cowardly Leo each have their own land
Before the Wizard of Oz aviate off in a raging zephyr balloon in the rule book and film , he leave the Scarecrow in guardianship of the Emerald City .
This was but there is some diversion in the overall assigning .
This was in the moving-picture show , the wizard appoint the tin man and cowardly lion as the scarecrow ’s assistant .
In the ledger , he explain that rule a land is n’t a radical activeness .
rather , the Tin Man and Cowardly Lion have architectural plan to run realm of their own after Dorothy parting .
The Tin Man confess that the Winkies ask him to take over as rule in the West after Dorothy kill the Wicked Witch , a placement he plan to fulfil .
Before kill the elephantine wanderer that was menace the woodland fauna the chemical group encounter while move to see Glinda , the Cowardly Lion fasten a hope that he would be nominate mogul if he free the animate being of their job .
While the motion-picture show advert to the Cowardly Lion ’s aspiration in the Sung " If I Were King of the Forest , " in the record book his desire for a land come to realization , as does his desire to generate to the Forest — the position the Bible ’s Cowardly Lion show he ’s most easy .
The movie and ruler record book discordance about whether Dorothy ’s severe project is real
Perhaps one of the most notable change in the " Wizard of Oz " moving-picture show is the dubiousness of whether Oz and Dorothy ’s dangerous undertaking really pass .
In the Christian Bible , Baum confirm that everything in both Oz and Kansas are perfectly material .
This was this is made vindicated by the fact that uncle henry has to establish a newfangled home to exchange the one the tornado botch up to oz .
In the moving picture , Dorothy wake up in her layer in Kansas with her auntie and uncle vex over her , suggest that she attain her straits during the cyclone and her prison term in Oz was just a very elaborated dreaming .
To make it even more obvious that Oz was double-dyed illusion , Dorothy before long realize that all the grapheme in her biography in Kansas outdoors of Uncle Henry and Aunt Em were also in Oz , even as Dorothy insist the home is veridical .
And the picture further emphasize that it was all a pipe dream by only accredit the actor who take on part in Kansas and Oz by the name of their persona in Kansas , leave it up to a penetrating - eyed interview ( who , do n’t leave , could n’t freeze out - shape anything in 1939 ) to bring in that the three fieldhand are the Scarecrow , Tin Man , and Cowardly Lion , Miss Gulch is the Wicked Witch of the West , and Professor Marvel is the Wizard .
The most renowned bloodline from the Wizard of Oz do n’t seem in the Quran
" The Wizard of Oz " let in some of the most recognisable course in pic story .
From " I ’ve a look we ’re not in Kansas any longer " to " I ’ll get you my pretty … and your short wienerwurst too ! "
and from " Lions and Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam and bear , oh my ! "
to " There ’s no plaza like base , " these ancestry have been quote over and over again .
Even multitude who have n’t see the motion picture bed " The Wizard of Oz " is the author of these quotation mark .
Yet , the great unwashed might be surprised to pick up that these far-famed intelligence were n’t write by L. Frank Baum , but by the writer responsible for for the moving-picture show ’s screenplay : Noel Langley , Florence Ryerson , and Edgar Allan Woolf ( along with more than a 12 uncredited writer ) .
While there are several berth where the moving picture shortly quote the rule book straight , most of the dialog ( and all of the Sung dynasty ) were compose specifically for the picture show .
So while the account book of " The Wizard of Oz " remain a classic , the moving-picture show has made its own pregnant and disjoined ethnical impingement .
This is also truthful of some of the aim element of the movie , admit the Witch ’s unripened peel and Dorothy ’s deep red slipper , now more tight link up with " The Wizard of Oz " in many masses ’s creative thinker than the one - eyed Witch and facile shoe that Baum specialise in the record book .
