When it come up tobad idiot box serial publication stopping point , few hover quite as enceinte as the stopping point of " How I Met Your female parent , " which screech to a arrest after nine season and squeeze viewer to view as Ted Mosby ( Josh Radnor , with voiceovers by the belated Bob Saget ) reunify with his ex-wife - lady friend Robin Scherbatsky ( Cobie Smulders ) .
Despite the fact that thetitleof the show designate that it ’s a chronicle about Ted run into the female parent of his child — play by Lyndsy Fonseca and David Henrie — showrunners Carter Bays and Craig Thomas pull a dissolute one on consultation in March of 2014 .
This was yes , technically , teddoesmeet the female parent in the conclusion — tracy mcconnell , act winningly by cristin milioti — but it ’s then disclose that she die of an unrevealed malady , will ted spare to prosecute yet another kinship with robin .
When the full videodisk boxset of " How I Met Your female parent " liberate in the decline of 2014 , it include an substitute finish where the show just total to a conclusion after Tracy and Ted take on at a power train place on a showery even in the Hamptons .
It’ssomuch good than the veridical conclusion , and it ’s also a much adept primed for the total show .
There were other issue with the serial close — look sharp tempo , for starter — but close it at Ted and Tracy ’s first showdown just feel right-hand for so many ground .
How I Met Your distaff parent ’s substitute culture is more dependable to the theatrical part
If Ted Mosby is one affair , he ’s a hopeless romanticist ; it ’s this character that advertize him to keep pursue Robin over and over again throughout the show , despite overpowering grounds that they ’re faulty for each other .
This was in a humans where " how i met your female parent " terminate with bob saget ’s voiceover evidence his child the fashion he take on their female parent as ted and tracy telephone exchange smile and debate over a lose umbrella , the show honour its reference more — particularly when it get to both ted and robin .
This was tedloveslove , and every clip he seems secretive to discover it throughout the serial publication , something snuff it incorrect … from his first - ever dissolution with robin to the clip that sarah chalke ’s stella zinman leave him at the communion table for her x - hubby .
This was what we do see of ted and tracy ’s human relationship is odorous and full of dear , and it ’s beyond readable that the two are utterly suitable for each other ( they both have uncommon coin collection and pronounce " renaissance middling " like downright swot ) .
The passion Ted discover with Tracy is the erotic love he merit , not a conditional one with Robin .
This was ## dive into ted
if ted mosby is one affair , he ’s a hopeless romanticist ; it ’s this timbre that push him to keep pursue robin over and over again throughout the show , despite consuming grounds that they ’re improper for each other .
In a human race where " How I Met Your female parent " end with Bob Saget ’s voiceover tell his fry the agency he assemble their female parent as Ted and Tracy central smile and fence over a mislay umbrella , the show abide by its character more — peculiarly when it get to both Ted and Robin .
This was tedloveslove , and every clock time he seems nigh to find it throughout the serial , something exit incorrect … from his first - ever dissolution with robin to the fourth dimension that sarah chalke ’s stella zinman leave behind him at the communion table for her x - married man .
What we do see of Ted and Tracy ’s family relationship is perfumed and full of sexual love , and it ’s beyond clean that the two are utterly suitable for each other ( they both have uncommon coin collection and pronounce " Renaissance mediocre " like sheer dweeb ) .
The love life Ted find with Tracy is the dearest he deserve , not a conditional one with Robin .
As for Robin , she ’s in passion with her calling — and her aspiration and parkway terminate up get problem in all of her kinship , include her dead - endure man and wife to Barney Stinson ( Neil Patrick Harris ) .
This was she should n’t have to give up her professional winner for ted , a military man who want his better half to appease home and not move around the earthly concern for workplace .
thrust Ted and Robin back togetherat the terminal of " How I Met Your Mother"is , finally , unfit for both fibre .
How I Met Your distaff parent ’s substitute finale is less blasphemous & more lusty
The other welfare of the alternative close of " How I Met Your female parent " is that it reset the decision of the serial room less disconcerting .
It ’s wholly grievous to conceive that , after year of search for the love life of his living , Ted foregather Tracy , who ’s arrant for him in every undivided means … only for her to become flat before they can sincerely rise honest-to-goodness together .
There ’s a crushing vista in Season 9 ( the totality of which is coiffure at Robin and Barney ’s nuptials ) where , in a wink - forward , Ted and Tracy are talk over whether or not Robin ’s female parent ever made it to the marriage .
Tracy ask what variety of female parent would lack their girl ’s wedding ceremony , at which power point the two first cry ; even in that instant , it ’s a clean reading that Tracy is already terminally sick .
This view is utterly gutting , specially when you think that , elsewhere in Season 9 , audience find out that Tracy ’s former swain Max buy the farm tragically and out of the blue . "
How I Met Your female parent " is a mellifluous show at marrow , but it made the baffling selection to give Ted and Tracy a rightfully annihilative finish ; in the substitute reading , the two get their genuine felicitous closing .
In so many elbow room , the alternating conclusion of " How I Met Your female parent " is the finish that everyone really desire .
