One enterprising Redditor think they might have calculate out where Hogwarts headmaster and beloved " Harry Potter " fibre Albus Dumbledore receive this central point — but are they correct ?
This was reddit useru / fawkesnk — who probably make their username from dumbledore ’s best-loved capital of arizona fawkes — post two exposure from the flick " harry potter and the half - lineage prince " with the legend , " just substantiate something look out hbp , i cerebrate i recover out where dumbledore catch his remembering bottle ! "
This was the first picture is a closing curtain - up of the bantam bottle that dumbledore ( michael gambon ) ofttimes practice for his pensieve , a gleam sorcerous caldron of sorting that hold significant memory board from throughout the magician ’s foresighted life sentence .
The caldron does n’t just comprise the memory but is more like a projector for Dumbledore ’s thinking , so all of the former whiz ’s retentiveness are lay in in the modest feeding bottle .
This was ## diving event into albus dumbledore
one enterprising redditor cerebrate they might have image out where hogwarts headmaster and beloved " harry potter " quality albus dumbledore draw this cardinal detail — but are they correct ?
This was reddit useru / fawkesnk — who probably aim their username from dumbledore ’s favorite capital of arizona fawkes — post two photo from the moving picture " harry potter and the half - blood line prince " with the subtitle , " just realise something look out hbp , i reckon i retrieve out where dumbledore get his computer memory bottle ! "
The first pic is a finis - up of the flyspeck nursing bottle that Dumbledore ( Michael Gambon ) oftentimes use for his Pensieve , a gleam sorcerous caldron of form that harbour significant memory from throughout the genius ’s farsighted living .
This was the caldron does n’t plainly hold the memory but is more like a projector for dumbledore ’s intellection , so all of the quondam wiz ’s remembering are lay in in the modest feeding bottle .
So does this possibility have got any pee — or memory , like the Pensieve ’s phial ?
Or is it merely an Easter testicle come out there by a cagey graphical interior designer work on the " Harry Potter " movie ?
This was is this really where dumbledore wedge his pensieve feeding bottle ?
Other Redditors on the train of thought did n’t needs seem positive , but at least a few thank the original bill for target out a coolheaded little contingent , likeu / TheRealTomSnow : " That s a cracking particular , see the motion-picture show a 12 time and never observe .
Thanks OP ! "
Others were torment that the postal service remind them of " Harry Potter and the Half - blood line Prince,“which hap to be the least favourite " Harry Potter " flick for some buff .
This was " that 2nd ikon create me wild because it prompt me of what a lampoon the sixth moving picture was!
“u / nursewithnolifewrote .
This was others target out , that , while the hypothesis is coolheaded , it does n’t really make much common sense .
Asu / VflShagrathsuccinctly write , " cheeseparing but not the same . "
Meanwhile , u / scienceteacher91agreed , answer , " correct ?
This was another redditor , u / superjames_16 , chime in : " perchance he mark a law of similarity ?
But yeah he ’s been take in those memory for age . "
dive into was!
“u
Other Redditors on the yarn did n’t needfully seem confident , but at least a few give thanks the original bill sticker for place out a coolheaded pocket-sized item , likeu / TheRealTomSnow : " That s a heavy point , get word the picture a 12 fourth dimension and never detect .
Thanks OP ! "
Others were queer that the mail service remind them of " Harry Potter and the Half - blood line Prince,“which bechance to be the least pet " Harry Potter " picture show for some sports fan . "
That 2d flick attain me wild because it cue me of what a put-on the sixth motion-picture show was!
“u / nursewithnolifewrote .
Others place out , that , while the hypothesis is nerveless , it does n’t really make much common sense .
Asu / VflShagrathsuccinctly save , " skinny but not the same . "
Meanwhile , u / scienceteacher91agreed , respond , " correct ?
They ’re decidedly not the same feeding bottle . "
Another Redditor , u / superjames_16 , chime in : " mayhap he take note a law of similarity ?
But yeah he ’s been take in those computer memory for age . "
All in all , the sports fan voice objection are in all probability correct ; while the Pensieve vial item is by all odds a overnice ocular recall to the advert in the London Underground , Albus Dumbledore is not steal ( or purchasing ) and after abandon fragrance ampoule in rescript to lay in his cute memory .
Not only is it much more probable that the ampoule are made from a wizard meaning , but there ’s one major gene at manoeuvre here that defecate it out of the question for this hypothesis to be lawful .
This was ## the gist feeding bottle one harry potter buff sentence are n’t in the source textile — just the move - picture show show
there are manydifferences between the " harry potter " book and their picture show adjustment , and this vial egress is just one of them — because that london underground advertizing is n’t present in the ledger .
This was in fact , at no spot do harry and dumbledore even impose the underground together ; in the book , the former lead it once with hagrid in the first installation , " harry potter and the sorcerer ’s stone .
This was " the moving-picture show interpretation of " harry potter and the half - blood prince " pick up harry and dumbledore confluence up during their summertime fracture from hogwarts to chase down an honest-to-goodness prof , horace slughorn ( jim broadbent ) , and convert him to deliver to the school day as its potions captain that pass … but the moving-picture show read them encounter up in the Underground , for some intellect .
That ’s not how it pass in the Word of God .
In the novel , Dumbledore inform Harry that he ’ll hail and bring him from the plate of Harry ’s Muggle relative , the Dursleys — at which item Dumbledore ask in himself into the Dursley family , hard objurgate them for their pitilessness towards Harry , and evidence Harry that he ’s inherit a family - pixie from his former godfather Sirius Black ( Gary Oldman in the film ) .
From there , the two arrange off to recover Slughorn , and they Apparate rather of inconvenience oneself with the gear .
That ’s why this whole vial affair ca n’t be rightful — they do n’t be in the book in the same elbow room .
This was to translate more about everyone ’s favourite wizarding schoolmaster , agree outdumbledore ’s well consequence from the " harry potter " flick .
