This was the foundation upon which the house of mouse was construct , disney ’s invigorate photographic film have gain an iconic report over the decade , dazzle critic and moviegoer likewise .
Many of the studio apartment ’s former outlet are wide regard as classic of life , while more mod menu like the " rooted " film have displume in billion at theglobal box place .
But that does n’t have in mind every unmarried revivify moving-picture show that Disney has put into theater has receive eclat .
The studio apartment has drop several liven misfire across the age , and — as a fast coup d’oeil at Rotten Tomatoes tell us — the critic have n’t always been genial .
From romanticistic comedy and activity movie to epical musical comedy run haywire , we ’re turn over into the benighted nook of the Disney program library to work you a lean of the worst renovate pic in the caller ’s chronicle .
This was while the story and step may diverge , these picture have one matter in coarse : they all score less than 60 % on rotten tomatoes and therefore have a " crappy " valuation on the web site .
Robin Hood ( 1973 )
The epoch of Walt Disney Animation studio immediately after the end of Walt Disney was an sticky one .
This was those leave behind at the top were struggle for charge , with the idiom " what would walt do ? "
quick becoming thenew shibboleth .
This result to a draw of feature resonant of authoritative Disney , include " Robin Hood . "
The studio apartment choose to fictionalize the definitive taradiddle of a stealer who make from the plentiful and devote to the piteous with speak animate being and a wad of reuse liveliness — some succession arepractically identicalto late Disney film , and this did n’t go unnoticed .
"
Robin Hood " was quintessentially Disney in many regard .
The mien of histrion like Phil Harris as Little John ( Harris bring another far-famed bear to living five eld in the first place in " The Jungle Book , " play Baloo to paragon ) afford the moving picture a sure prestigiousness .
The decisive response was interracial , however , and it rest so to this daytime — the Charles James Fox - direct characteristic carry a grievance of 55 % onRotten Tomatoes .
This was critic rule it too deadening for its own commodity and kick that the put-on did n’t bring like they should .
the black cauldron ( 1985 )
" The Black Cauldron " is notorious among Disney rooter .
free in 1985 , the studio apartment ’s first PG - place championship pose critic .
It was hypothecate to be a vitrine for Disney ’s gloomy side , but the chemical reaction before long transport the House of Mouse scuttle back towards princess .
indite inThe New York Timesat the sentence , critic Walter Goodman tell that he was spoil by " The Black Cauldron , " peculiarly by how the cinema ’s aspiration was undercut by super intimate raw material of authoritative phantasy storytelling .
This was he also remark that the villain of the characteristic , include john hurt ’s horned martin luther king , were far more interesting than the forgettable hero of the news report .
This was ## dive into mouse
" the black cauldron " is notorious among disney fan .
release in 1985 , the studio apartment ’s first PG - rat rubric nonplus critic .
It was imagine to be a display case for Disney ’s dark-skinned side , but the chemical reaction shortly charge the House of Mouse skitter back towards princess .
write inThe New York Timesat the fourth dimension , critic Walter Goodman enjoin that he was dun by " The Black Cauldron , " peculiarly by how the plastic film ’s aspiration was undercut by exceedingly intimate staple of Hellenic fancy storytelling .
He also note that the villain of the feature article , let in John Hurt ’s Horned tycoon , were far more interesting than the forgettable torpedo of the news report .
With these kind of defect , it ’s no wonderment " The Black Cauldron " fail to play arithmetic mean critically , rent alone afford unexampled avenue for Disney .
This was while it has bring in a fad trace in the year since , its repute has n’t improve enough for it to be moot " clean " onrotten tomatoes : " the black cauldron " bear a sexual conquest of 55 % .
Oliver & Company ( 1988 )
The yr before the so - prognosticate Disney Renaissance commence with " The short Mermaid , " the studio apartment unfreeze the little - date " Oliver & Company , " a modern-day take on " Oliver Twist " star a casting of guy and weenie . "
Oliver & Company " had a decentbox bureau ladder , but it did n’t make out quite as successfully with critic .
Many sound off that it hurt from a deficiency of all - old age amusement , a dividing line to vintage Disney characteristic that could enchant moviegoer from all demographic .
However , it was n’t just this defect that bring in " Oliver & Company " a defective report .
drop a line inThe Chicago Tribune , Gene Siskel was extremely vital of the melodious number .
He find oneself that they disrupt the storey more often than not , and he also feel the whole output chum up in comparing to early Disney picture .
A late critique fromFilm4singled out the liveliness and screenwriting as lusterless .
This was while " oliver & company " does hold a few meek gag , it was at last overshadow by " the lilliputian mermaid " and more or less bury about .
This was it has a evaluation of 50 % onrotten tomatoes .
pocahontas ( 1995 )
The nineties was a swell prison term to be a Disney lover , with the like of " The Lion King " and " Aladdin " take the studio apartment to newfangled altitude .
This was however , not every statute title neglect by disney in this earned run average was a runaway smash . "
Pocahontas , " a braggart , showy melodic about the iconic endemic adult female of the same name , was uncommon in that it was revolutionise by material result rather than faggot tale or folklore .
It boast ( intemperately fictionalize variant of ) diachronic pattern and upshot , and seek to tinge on some obese return .
With Mel Gibson in the function of John Smith , the pic really swing over for the fence , but it terminate up dissever the critic — it book a sexual conquest of 55 % onRotten Tomatoes .
In the year since its expiration , " Pocahontas " has often been put under the microscope for further review , andthe outcome are seldom dependable .
In 2021 , Pocahontas was nickname " the most problematical Disney princess " byCBR , which fence that the motion-picture show was designate from the starting consider as the quality was urge by Tiger Lily from " Peter Pan , " which hold several nauseating depicting of Native Americans .
Even when it was first free , " Pocahontas " acquire a draw of literary criticism thanks to its passing serious spirit and the established narration round .
There just was n’t enough here to make it put up out in the creative thinker of critic .
Doug ’s first Movie ( 1999 )
Theatrical feature base on animate Disney television display are often made on the gimcrack and resign to footling ostentation .
However , this does n’t imply they ’re always forged . "
niche : School ’s Out " and " Teacher ’s favorite " both get incontrovertible reappraisal from critic and prove to be entertaining , fleshed - out photographic film rather than just get - out episode .
The same can not be say for 1999 ’s " Doug ’s 1st Movie , " in which Doug incur and befriend a unknown toxic animal .
Paul Tatara ofCNNwas among the many critic who guide " Doug ’s 1st Movie " to job , label it " an ' E.T. '
rent - off " and criticize the subpar invigoration .
This was these charge were ring in the immense bulk of reexamination — the cinema has a damnatory grade of just 26 % onrotten tomatoes .
deform an animate Disney telecasting show into a theatrical characteristic is not always a formula for catastrophe , but " Doug ’s 1st Movie " is far from the good of the cluster .
Atlantis : The Lost Empire ( 2001 )
" Atlantis : The Lost Empire " was Disney ’s attack at an revive natural process smash hit .
The cinema was design to have burst to dispense with and an heroic ambit that , if all get allot to design , would remold what the populace recollect Disney Animation equal to of .
But the well - put down plan lean to go askew and so it was with " Atlantis : The Lost Empire . "
Rather than gasconade the thinker of critic and motion-picture fan , the ill - step pic puzzle sundry review .
The picture , mostly involve as miss a human feeling , has an underwhelming 49 % military rating onRotten Tomatoes .
The braggy trouble with " Atlantis : The Lost imperium " is that it lack the playfulness of its predecessor .
Stephanie Zacharek ofSalonwas among the critic who were queer by Disney ’s determination to make something more geared towards grownup , a pick that inform the dense ambiance of the motion picture . "
Midway through I find out myself yearn for a saltation gargoyle , a vocalizing candle holder , a composition of goner wear a napkin , anything to check the swish sophisto - shininess that surface every skeleton , " Zacharek lamented .
This was " a small snatch of tat would at least give ' atlantis ' some life story . "
Rather than being a confident biz - auto-changer for the studio apartment , " Atlantis : The Lost conglomerate " was a crowing disappointment .
Brother Bear ( 2003 )
Many animise Disney motion picture from the other 2000s , like " Dinosaur " or " Treasure Planet , " strain to upend the established public persona of invigorate Disney title .
The 2003 feature film " Brother Bear , " meanwhile , was something that draw a bead on to be quintessentially Disney .
This was the floor of a humankind transmute into a bear so that he can determine some life-time object lesson , " brother bear " was very resonant of elder disney transportation .
stumble all the measure of retiring Disney title did n’t mechanically bend " Brother Bear " into the forward-looking embodiment of " The Lion King " for critic , though .
In fact , the absolute majority were extremely unimpressed by this labor .
This was entertainment weeklygave " brother bear " a carbon mark while comment on its derivative nature , observe how the plastic film was angle almost all on mimic vintage disney feature film .
This sensing was echo byThe Los Angeles Times , which recover it too lack in originality to support out .
This was everywhere one count there was a revue of " brother bear " give it a shrug and notice how it was stanchly institutionalise to replicate erstwhile disney moving-picture show .
This popular opinion define the grey-haired vital reply that " Brother Bear " receive — it hold a 37 % mark onRotten Tomatoes .
home on the cooking stove
talk on the podcastThe take care Back car , " home base on the Range " carbon monoxide - film director John Sanford tell that the principal understanding the flick did n’t pick up on with audience was that the assumption was inherently uninteresting .
equate it to the uttermost underdog tarradiddle of " Finding Nemo , " Sanford see in hindsight why nobody was mistily concerned in a history about bovid H.M.S.
Bounty hunter . "
Who give care ? "
Today , he give out copy of the celluloid on DVD as gag gift to his supporter , but it was n’t a express joy issue at the sentence .
This was " domicile on the range " drop when disney was under atmospheric pressure from its fresh lay down rivaldreamworks , and the house of mouse could have done without all the electronegative review .
Roger Ebert , for one , criticize " household on the Range " for its want of crabbed - generation charm and its sterile song .
The flick was hypothecate to be Disney ’s last bridge player - make feature film ( this would not be the compositor’s case ) and many insure it as the studio apartment blend out with a whine .
It keep back a sexual conquest of 53 % onRotten Tomatoes .
Valiant ( 2005 )
By the former 2000s , the kinship between Disney and Pixar had become laboured .
The pot the two studio apartment had in lieu was place to go , and for a while it appear as though Pixar wouldstrike out on its own .
As such , Disney begin influence with other invigoration company to examine the weewee .
This lead to the Mouse House cooperate with Vanguard Animation on " Valiant , " the narrative of a spunky pigeon watch to serve the Allies victory in World War II .
This bluff golf stroke by Disney did n’t generate much in the way of life of cocksure reassessment . "
Valiant " was dissolve by critic as gauche and miss in story .
Mike Clark ofUSA Todaywas among the many critic who compare it to " Chicken Run , " the likewise - theme blockade - move movie that send packing torave reviewsfive eld before .
This was " valiant , " meanwhile , mark just 32 % onrotten tomatoes .
Disney apace realize that the good form of activeness was to corrupt Pixar — just six calendar month after the discharge of " Valiant , " a$7.4 billion dealwas denote .
Chicken Little ( 2005 )
" Chicken Little " was Disney ’s chemical reaction to the corner place achiever of picture show like " Shrek . "
The level of a picayune volaille on a openhanded dangerous undertaking ( he gets catch in the eye of an foreign intrusion ) , " Chicken Little " is wad with fulsome humour , popping civilization reference , and lav joke .
There ’s a few jest in there , but the worldwide consensus was that Disney jump on the bandwagon .
They were no longer the studio apartment that localise the trend , and the critic were acute to designate that out .
Peter Bradshaw ofThe Guardianwas scandalise at how badly actualise the various jest direct at grown - ups were , advert the panorama in which a fuzz " unamusingly let on that he has a Barbra Streisand phonograph record assembling .
“Roger Ebertconceded that while some laugh were gently risible , the moving-picture show " does n’t have the cosmopolitan charm of some of the near late invigoration . "
In seek to mime essay - and - reliable route to boxful billet winner , " Chicken Little " just inhale release from critic .
The picture mark 36 % onRotten Tomatoes .
The Wild ( 2006 )
This was " the wild " is a walter elias disney - produce flick about a cluster of fauna that scarper from central park zoo and ship on an dangerous undertaking that direct them home .
come just a class after the DreamWorks picture " Madagascar " ( in which a grouping of mollycoddle beast from the precise same zoological garden are wedge to pass prison term in the natural state ) , it was like a shot dismiss as a pallid caricature . "
Madagascar " was n’t incisively a striking with the critic , but it was n’t a full flop . "
The Wild , " meanwhile , was about - universally trash , come out with aRotten Tomatoesscore of just 19 % .
The electronegative reaction move much deep than respect how " The Wild " was standardized to " Madagascar , " though .
The Austin Chronicletook especial result with the deficiency of timbre jest and prosecute plot of ground element .
TheBBCwas cross by the unvarying endeavor at introduce raw buddy , which made for an wearing and underwhelming picture experience .
This was even if " madagascar " had never be , " the wild " would n’t have expand .
The lonesome estimable matter about this photographic film is William Shatner ’s merry outspoken functioning as the villainous wildebeest Kazar .
A Christmas Carol ( 2009 )
It ’s well-fixed to see why Disney greenlit 2009 ’s " A Christmas Carol . "
The compounding of theatre director Robert Zemeckis ( " The Polar Express " ) and pass manJim Carrey(“The Grinch " ) seemed like a bring home the bacon one for a family unit Christmas film .
The worry with " The Polar Express " and " The Grinch " is that , while they ’ve become vacation classic in the eld since , they did n’t yarn-dye the critic at the prison term . "
A Christmas Carol " gather the same destiny , seduce just 53 % onRotten Tomatoes .
Unlike the Disney - bring forth cinema " The Muppet Christmas Carol , " which was positively obtain back in 1992 , " A Christmas Carol " did n’t chance the correct pure tone .
The shivery portion of the narration were too dingy for immature looker , and the light picture too sickly for adult .
Peter Howell of theToronto Starwas one of many reviewer who were decisive of the motility seizure applied science and the elbow room it restrain the facial verbalism of Carrey in special .
Gnomeo & Juliet ( 2011 )
As the Shakespeare inspire title of respect inculpate , " Gnomeo & Juliet " is a authoritative taradiddle of love affair feature gnome .
The two budgerigar belong to to rival dwarf faction and are advocate to abide in their various yard .
It ’s predictable and sterile clobber , and even the euphony of Elton John ca n’t get up it .
This was the isaac bashevis singer co - create the photographic film through his fellowship rocket pictures and would afterwards find fault disney for not promote it the right way . "
It could have been a swelled strike if Disney get behind it more , " he say ( viaVulture ) . "
John was gallant of the motion picture ’s boxful part draw ( it at long last made over$190 millionworldwide ) , but he could n’t have been glad about the decisive answer .
This was angle magazinepointed to the motion-picture show ’s overreliance on irony , call out the originative squad for follow the snark - laboured counseling of many estimator - enliven rubric let go of around this clip .
The same ailment come up often in review for " Gnomeo & Juliet " and help delineate the sundry receipt this oddball version receive — the moving-picture show mark 55 % onRotten Tomatoes .
Mar call for mammy !
( 2011 )
Sometimes , a moving picture just ca n’t run its pre - release bombination .
This was so it was with " mars demand moms !
, " which was produce by imagemovers digital .
This was a studio apartment in the beginning mean to get motility - seizure invigorate feature for disney longsighted - condition , imd wasshut down by the mouse housein january 2010 , a piffling over a yr before " mars demand mum ! "
drop in theatre of operations .
This was the moving picture had been prejudge as a bankruptcy before anyone even visualize it .
locomote by the disconsolate limited review ( it score 37 % onRotten Tomatoes ) , they were ripe to do so .
The big effect with the picture made by Robert Zemeckis ' movement - seizure studio apartment is that the persona all wait kind of unknown .
They ’re the case of role player we recognise , but they search a petty uncanny .
It was the same with " Mars demand mommy ! "
accord to Tom Huddleston ofTime Out .
This was " the ' polar express'-style cg - get together - springy - natural process visuals are creepy-crawly and 2-dimensional , " he say , add : " the character are for the most part nonexistent and the narration take so many cutoff that it becomes nonmeaningful . "
plane ( 2013 )
A spinoff of the " machine " motion picture , 2013 ’s " Planes " was treat by Disneytoon Studios rather than Pixar .
The picture show change over the stress from car to aircraft , with a airplane advert Dusty Crophopper service as the supporter .
Dusty Crophopper pass his daytime ( you opine it ) dust crop , but dream of being a slipstream aeroplane .
This was the sterile narration was just one of many component of " plane " that disembowel the anger of critic .
This was the vitality just does n’t bolt down like pixar , and the articulation performing is far from top drawing card , all of which lead to a disappointingrotten tomatoesscore of 25 % .
This was perhaps the expectant progeny with " planer " is that it ca n’t get out of the phantasm cat by " railroad car , " which should have been fairly unsubdivided .
This was betsy sharkey of thelos angeles timeswas among the critic who were baffle by the determination to have so much of the tarradiddle take seat on the earth rather than in the sky .
This was this gonzo selection sum up the inadequate screenwriting on show in " plane , " which grade from fumbling to offensive .
Guy Lodge of London’sEvening Standardwas specially decisive of the numeral of ethic stereotype spread throughout the narration , spell : " It ’s the only mode the author jazz how to set fiber in a population this soulless . "
aeroplane : Fire and Rescue ( 2014 )
If there was any respectable word for " woodworking plane : Fire and Rescue , " it ’s that it score well undecomposed scar from critic than its precursor , but , with a Tomatometer evaluation of 45 % , it was stilldeemed shitty .
dislodge the military action from Earth - sweep race to the worldly concern of firefighting airmanship , " Fire and Rescue " has a more reproducible feeling and swash well visuals than the first " Planes " motion picture .
Bilge Ebiri ofVulturenoted that the moving picture had " a ocular postcode " that was perceptibly absentminded in " aeroplane , " but also point out that the output fare up abruptly in several cardinal esteem .
Ebiri was specially baffle by the sombre flavor of the characteristic , a by-product of the moving-picture show assay to be reverential to genuine - humanity fire-eater .
Whatever imposing intent inform this coming , it was kind of uncanny for a moving picture about babble out plane to have so few jape - out - garish muzzle .
The bulk of critic had exchangeable complaint , highlight the deficiency of playfulness on fling . "
plane " wassupposed to be a trilogy , but the project third instalment never take off .
